Leading Coin Shop in Hartland, WI

Costa’s Fine Jewelry and Coins

Are you looking for a reliable and trusted coin shop near Hartland, WI? Costa's Fine Jewelry and Coins is your premier destination for buying, selling, and appraising rare coins, bullion, and numismatic treasures. Whether you're an experienced collector or just starting your coin investment journey, our knowledgeable team is here to offer expert guidance. Visit us or contact us today to explore our extensive selection and see why Costa’s is the go-to coin shop serving the Hartland area.

Why Choose Costa’s Fine Jewelry and Coins?

Costa’s Fine Jewelry and Coins stands out for its vast selection of rare and valuable coins. From bullion to highly sought-after rare coins, our shop offers a diverse collection tailored to meet the needs of both collectors and investors. But what truly sets us apart is our commitment to education and personalized service.

Wide Selection

Explore a wide variety of rare coins, numismatic coins, and bullion coins, each with a unique story. Whether you're looking for U.S. coins or international collectibles, our inventory caters to every collector’s interest.

Expert Guidance

Our team of experienced numismatists provides valuable insights into market trends and the historical significance of each piece, helping you make well-informed decisions.

Trusted Dealers

As trusted coin dealers, we prioritize building long-term relationships with our customers through transparent and

honest service.

Exploring the World of Numismatics with

Costa’s Fine Jewelry and Coins

Numismatics, the collection of coins and paper currency, offers both a rewarding hobby and strong investment potential. At Costa's Fine Jewelry and Coins, we specialize in numismatic coins, including rare pieces sought after for both their historical and financial value.

Rare Coins

Our rare coin collection includes highly sought-after U.S. coins, such as the Morgan Silver Dollar, as well as ancient treasures like the Roman Denarius. These coins are not only investments but windows into history.

Image of rare numismatic coins and bullion.
Image of an american buffalo rare coin

Bullion Coins

For those looking to invest in gold and silver, we offer a variety of bullion coins. These coins are a reliable investment, as their value is tied to the current market prices of the metals they contain.

Expert Appraisals

Whether you’re new to numismatics or a seasoned collector, our team provides expert appraisals to help you assess the value of your collection or make informed decisions on new investments.

Image of proof coins.

Why Invest in Gold and Silver Coins?

Investing in gold and silver coins is a smart strategy for protecting your wealth and diversifying your portfolio. At Costa’s Fine Jewelry and Coins, we offer premium bullion coins that hold intrinsic value, driven by the precious metals they contain.

Image of rare bullions.

Long-Term Value

Gold and silver bullion coins are considered a stable investment, particularly during periods of economic uncertainty. These coins tend to hold or increase in value over time, making them a solid option for long-term investors.

Variety of Options

Whether you prefer coins from the U.S. Mint or the Royal Canadian Mint, our team is here to guide you in selecting the best coins to match your investment goals.

Image of rare numismatic coins on separate container.

Costa’s Expertise in Rare Coin Buying and Selling

Costa’s Fine Jewelry and Coins is the trusted destination for those looking to buy or sell rare coins in the greater Hartland area. We specialize in evaluating and purchasing rare coins, and our reputation as trustworthy coin dealers has made us a local favorite for collectors and sellers alike.

Competitive Offers

If you're looking to sell your rare coins, we provide accurate appraisals and offer competitive prices. Whether you're selling a single piece or an entire collection, we ensure a smooth, transparent process.

Rare Coin Collection

Our inventory features coins with historical significance, such as the Morgan Silver Dollar and Gold 20 Francs. These are just a few examples of the rare coins that are highly sought after by collectors worldwide.

THE COSTA'S DIFFERENCE



At Costa's Fine Jewelry & Coins, we are dedicated to making high-quality

bullion coin investments accessible to all. What sets us apart from other coin

dealers in Waukesha and the surrounding areas is our unwavering commitment to

exceptional value. We travel nationwide, attending rare coin shows and conventions,

to bring you the finest selection and expertise the industry has to offer.


Unmatched Expertise: Our team, led by appraisers with the highest experience,

brings years of knowledge and passion to every interaction. Whether you're

selecting your first Gold Eagle or expanding your rare coin collection, you can trust

our guidance in the world of investment-grade coins.



Competitive Pricing: We've built strong relationships with suppliers and mints,

allowing us to offer competitive prices on investment-grade coins without

compromising on quality. Experience the benefits of owning precious metal coins at

fair market values.



Personalized Service: As a family-owned business, we understand the importance

of personal attention in coin investments. We take the time to listen to your

investment goals, answer your questions, and ensure you find the perfect

investment-grade coins for your portfolio.

WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS SAY

Quote

I've been collecting investment-grade coins for years, and Costa's is my go-to place in Waukesha. Their knowledge is phenomenal!


Andre S

Quote

The team at Costa's helped me start my Gold Eagle collection. I couldn't be happier with their guidance and prices.


Sarah L

Quote

I inherited some old coins and wasn't sure of their value. Costa's authentication service was incredibly helpful for reselling


Peter B

Quote

I always find the coins im looking for at Costa's.


Josie C

Quote

The rare coins I've purchased from Costa's have significantly appreciated in value.


Laura W

Quote

Reliable company to assist in selling coins. They are super honest with pricing!


Tanner O

Frequently Asked Questions

What Types of Coins Does Your Shop Specialize In?

At Costa’s Fine Jewelry and Coins, we specialize in a wide range of coins, including rare U.S. coins, historical numismatic coins, and ancient collectibles. Our inventory also includes high-quality bullion coins made from gold, silver, and other precious metals.

How Do I Determine the Value of My Coin Collection?

Our team provides professional appraisals based on rarity, condition, and market demand. We take the time to educate you on the value of each piece and help you understand the factors that influence a coin’s worth.

Are Bullion Coins a Good Investment?

Yes! Bullion coins made from precious metals like gold and silver are an excellent hedge against inflation and economic volatility. These coins tend to hold or even increase in value over time, especially during uncertain economic periods.

Can I Sell My Rare Coins at Costa’s Fine Jewelry and Coins?

Absolutely! We specialize in purchasing rare coins and offer competitive prices. Bring your coins in for a free evaluation and our team will guide you through the process.

Do You Offer Coin Appraisals?

Yes, we provide expert appraisals to help you understand the value of your collection. Our certified staff uses industry-standard grading techniques to ensure accurate assessments.

Ready to Start Your Numismatic Journey?

Whether you're interested in buying rare coins, bullion, or numismatic collectibles, Costa’s Fine Jewelry and Coins is your trusted partner for all things coin-related in the greater Hartland area. Visit us today to explore our expert services and diverse inventory. Our team is ready to help you buy, sell, or appraise your collection.

Don’t wait—take the first step now! Call us at (262) 360-5516 or contact Costa’s Fine Jewelry and Coins to begin your numismatic journey today!

Costa's Fine Jewelry and Coins in Waukesha offers competitive prices on fine diamonds, rare gemstones, and bullions. Family-owned, we specialize in engagement rings, GIA-certified diamonds, jewelry repair, and estate buying.

Get in Touch

Hours of Operation
10am-5pm Tuesday

10am–6pm Wed–Fri

10am-3pm Saturday

Get an Update

Don’t forget about upcoming holidays and promotions. Sign up below, you’ll never miss out. 

Copyright © 2025. Powered by Raging Agency.

Follow us

Copyright © 2025. Powered by Raging Agency.

Follow us